Walmart+ vs Amazon Subscribe & Save
This website contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. The content on this website was created with the help of AI.
As shopping habits continue to evolve in the digital age, consumers are increasingly looking for convenient ways to manage their household essentials.
Two major contenders have emerged in the subscription-based shopping arena, each offering unique advantages for different shopping needs.
When comparing Walmart+ vs Amazon Subscribe & Save, shoppers must consider factors beyond just price—including delivery timeframes, product selection, membership benefits, and how each service might complement their existing shopping patterns.
Understanding the nuances between these two retail giants’ subscription models can help households optimize their budget while maintaining a well-stocked home.
Key Takeaways
- Walmart+ is cheaper at $98/year compared to Amazon Prime’s $139/year
- Both offer 30-day free trials and student discounts
- Free grocery delivery with a $35 minimum purchase for both services
- Amazon Prime includes music and video streaming; Walmart+ offers video-only
- Walmart+ provides up to 10 cents per gallon discount on fuel
- Amazon Prime offers more mature services like Try Before You Buy for clothing
- The choice depends on individual shopping habits and preferences
Membership Pricing and Value Comparison
We’ve analyzed grocery subscriptions to find the best savings for you. Our study covers major online grocery services. We looked at pricing, delivery fees, and membership perks.
Monthly and Annual Subscription Costs
Grocery subscriptions offer different prices and benefits. Walmart+ costs $98 yearly or $12.95 monthly. Amazon Prime, including Fresh, is pricier at $139 yearly or $14.99 monthly.
Instacart+ offers a middle option at $99 per year. It’s a good choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
| Service | Annual Cost | Monthly Cost | Free Delivery Threshold |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walmart+ | $98 | $12.95 | $35+ |
| Amazon Prime | $139 | $14.99 | $35-$50+ |
| Instacart+ | $99 | N/A | $35+ |
Free Trial Periods and Student Discounts
Most grocery subscriptions offer 30-day free trials. Students can get big discounts on Amazon Prime Student. It costs $7.49 monthly or $69 yearly.
Walmart+ gives a 50% discount through its Assist program. This offer is for eligible customers.
Additional Savings Opportunities
Subscriptions offer more than free delivery. Walmart+ members get fuel discounts, and Amazon Prime subscribers enjoy exclusive Prime Day deals.
Some services have credit card perks. The Prime Visa for Amazon adds value for frequent shoppers.
Consider your shopping habits when choosing a subscription. Online shopping costs about 10% more than in-store shopping, but memberships can save money for regular users.
Grocery Delivery Comparison
Walmart+ and Amazon Subscribe & Save offer unique grocery delivery features. We’ve analyzed these services to help you choose wisely. Both have their strengths and cater to different needs.
Delivery Coverage Areas and Minimums
Walmart+ and Amazon have different coverage areas. Amazon Fresh serves many urban centers. Walmart+ uses its physical stores for wider reach.
Both require a $35 minimum order for free delivery. This threshold ensures efficient service for customers and providers alike.
Same-Day Delivery Options
Walmart+ offers one-hour delivery windows for orders over $35. Amazon Prime provides two-hour windows for orders exceeding $100 through Amazon Fresh or Whole Foods.
| Service | Delivery Window | Minimum Order |
|---|---|---|
| Walmart+ | 1 hour | $35 |
| Amazon Prime | 2 hours | $100 |
Food Selection and Quality
Amazon Fresh offers many specialty and gourmet items through its Whole Foods connection. Walmart+ provides a wide range of everyday groceries at competitive prices.
Availability of Fresh Products
Walmart+ uses its many physical stores to ensure fresh product availability. This network allows for quick delivery in many areas.
Amazon Fresh excels in urban areas with its dedicated warehouses. However, it’s not as widespread as Walmart+.
“Fresh produce delivery is a game-changer for busy families.”
Both services aim to make grocery shopping more convenient. Your choice may depend on where you live and what you need.
Premium Membership Benefits Beyond Shopping
Walmart+ and Amazon Prime offer more than just shopping perks. Let’s explore the extra benefits that make these memberships worthwhile.
These perks can greatly enhance your subscription’s value.
Amazon Prime excels with its entertainment package. Members enjoy Prime Video, Music, and Gaming, which provide countless hours of streaming content.
Prime Reading offers a huge e-book library, while Amazon Photos gives unlimited photo storage.
Walmart+ takes a different approach to extra perks. It offers a free Paramount+ Essential subscription for TV and movie fans.
In-store shoppers can use mobile scan-and-go for quick checkouts.
Walmart+ also provides fuel discounts at participating stations. This perk can lead to big savings over time. Both services offer prescription benefits for members.
Amazon’s RxPass costs $5 monthly for select medications. Walmart+ members can save on prescriptions at Walmart pharmacies.
Your choice may depend on which extras best suit your lifestyle.
| Benefit | Amazon Prime | Walmart+ |
|---|---|---|
| Video Streaming | Prime Video | Paramount+ Essential |
| Music Streaming | Prime Music | – |
| Gaming | Prime Gaming | – |
| E-books | Prime Reading | – |
| Photo Storage | Amazon Photos | – |
| In-Store Shopping | – | Mobile Scan-and-Go |
| Fuel Discounts | – | Yes |
| Prescription Benefits | RxPass ($5/month) | Pharmacy Savings |
Conclusion
Walmart+ and Amazon Subscribe & Save offer unique advantages for subscription savings.
Walmart+ shines with affordable pricing and fuel savings. Amazon Prime excels in entertainment and diverse shopping perks.
Local store availability and delivery options are crucial in choosing the right service. Walmart Grocery focuses on low prices and price matching.
Amazon Fresh provides free two-hour delivery for Prime members on qualifying orders.
Instacart offers multiple delivery options and a wide range of stores. When considering grocery delivery, weigh the costs against the benefits.
A 15-20% tip is recommended for delivery, while pickup is often free.
Subscription boxes and meal kits offer convenience but may not always save money. This is especially true for larger households. The best choice depends on your specific needs and lifestyle.
You can try free trials to test features before committing. The right service can save time and money and make grocery shopping more efficient and enjoyable.
